By Juan Montoya
"The road to hell is paved with good intentions..."
If anything, you've got to hand it to the Brownsville Independent School District board majority members for their overweening ambition.
They incurred the wrath of the parents and students at Veterans Memorial High School with their plans to convert the new $75 million facility into a magnet college preparatory campus for science technology and the medical professions.
But critics say that despite the assurances that the administration and board are attempting to recapture students that have enrolled in alternative programs offered here, in Harlingen and in Mercedes that are draining BISD of brain power and federal student-attendance funds, the basics have been abandoned in the effort.
Local critics say (they asked for anonymity) say that instead of trying to turn Veterans into a pre-med facility and scientist incubator, the BISD administration and board should instead concentrate on teaching students the "three R's."
"Look at the class of 2010 that enrolled at Texas Southmost College," said one, showing a printout generated by the TSC admissions office. "Nearly half (46.5 percent) are not college ready. They have to take remedial classes. Of the dual-enrolled students , 31.3 are not college ready (384 of 1,227) . In math only, a sample of 255 indicates that 66.4 percent don't pass muster. In reading that number is 52.1 percent (of 200) , and in writing, 44.5 (of 171 not ready) don't cut it either. In the Fall 2010, TSC enrollment indicate that of 2,193 new students admitted to the community college, 1,227 were dual enrollment students, and 966 were non-dual students.
The non-dual enrollment total (966) fared even worse. Only 34.2 percent were college ready. The rest (65.8) of those graduates were not ready for college A full 74.8 percent (of a 476 sample) were not college ready in math , 63.2 (of a sample of 402) were not ready in reading, and 60.7 (of a sample of 386) were not-college ready in writing.
"The dual-enrolment students are supposed to be the cream of the crop and half of them can't even read or write at college level," he said. "In math they're even worse. And they want to run a pre-med program at Veterans?"
During the campaign last time around for vacancies at the TSC board of trustees, candidates pointed to the dismal educational situation at the BISD, but also at the abysmal performance of the TSC-UTB hybrid run by President Juliet Garcia and her cohorts.
"Once they graduate from BISD and go on to TSC, the majority of students have to take remedial classes," said a candidate at the time. "After a year or two they run out of grants and they have to drop out because they can't afford the high cost of tuition and fees there. And even if they do make it into the university, their chances of success are abysmal."
The TSC-UTB "partnership's" performance is so bad that the school could not even be ranked with other schools that shared similar characteristics. In fact, the Melinda and Bill Gates Foundation gave the city millions to address its 50 percent freshman retention rate, its 17 percent graduation rate over six years, and
the high cost of tuition and fees imposed upon one of the poorest segments in American society.
New TSC president Lily Tercero – unlike Garcia who never owned up to her dismal performance and her perpetuation of the high college costs – has taken the bull by the horns and addressed this an an overriding issue facing TSC.
She said that the state average is $66 per credit hour, but that TSC charges about $200 per credit hour.
"It is something that we will look at and should be addressed," she told the local daily. "That is our plan."
Be that as it may, for one city resident, the emphasis that the current BISD board and administration in putting on pre-med and science instruction at the Veterans magnet school is missing the mark altogether.
"If a student is going to go to med school, he has to take the basic courses first," he said.
"The first thing you have to do is teach them the basics like reading, writing and arithmetic. Once they get in college they have to pass those first before they're even allowed into a pre-med program. If half of your students aren't graduating college ready, why focus the resources on the few that are? The mission of the BISD should be to graduate people who can read, write and add and subtract. Anything else is delusional."
Tuesday, October 11, 2011
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
19 comments:
No beer for you!
The Beer Nazi
Finally I can agree with one of your your posts. They need to clean up their act before trying to take on my issues. Real vocational programs would be a good start.
The only thing more alarming than those dual enrollment statistics is BISD's "Ready, Fire, Aim" approach towards making this change. Delusional IS definitely the most appropriate term to define this fiasco in the making.
I feel so sorry for these young people because they are not being taught the basics to make it in college. Too many lazy teachers who can't teach without a book in hand because they don't know the material themselves. SAD
I substituted for a long time and I know what I am talking about.
I substituted for a teacher who handed out word puzzles every single day. The students were trained like robots to complete this work and be graded on this.
This work had no relavence to anything as it was a way to control the students and not be bothered. She taught after school and at night at the college so she was always too tired. The students hated her but were too scared to say anything.
I mentioned this to someone at the school and was labeled a trouble-maker. I was never called again.
So you see sometimes people like her are rewarded and our kids are sacrificed.
Of course they are going to be in remedial classes with teachers like her.
I also want to say that we have some great teachers who are doing a great job but the some kids just don't care.
I have often disagreed with your posting but not so on this one. There is nothing wrong with a well planned magnet school that offers an opportunity for all students (including trade and industrial studies)but the "three R's" is definitely much needed to ensure success for all students. Please do some investigating research to see how many students (STSD, BISD) are admitted to the UTB-TSC Nursing programs the year after graduating from high school.
Consider this, the UT side of the erstwhile partnership is doing everything possible to greatly expand the Dual Enrollment Program from the campus. You will recall that one Director of Enrollment Management was vilified up one side and down another (quite rightly) for her single-minded determination to increase enrollment at the expense of standards. Now it is all happening again, and no one is there to stop it. The controls created after much debate in the Academic Senate a couple of years ago have been suspended or trampled in the dust, so we are back to the same old game. Someone needs to tell TSC about this because there is a reason why UTB is surreptitiously pushing this ill-advised expansion without consulting with its "partner".
Call or write Dr. Lily Tercero. I am sure she would be interested in your input.
Thank God, this FIASCO was stopped!!!
Awesome post! I am a avid reader of the BV and have been critical about your blog. Dig into this subject and I guarantee a bigger readership. And it is true, but TSC/Garcia would throw many students under the bus to get that money in the remedial classes. What a bitch!
UTB-TSC might have succeeded as a concept if BISD produced students who were prepared for college. Most BISD grads are illiterate in two languages. BISD is a social diploma mill and public day care for families who don't give a shit about education. BISD administrators are overpaid, yet fight to protect their "honey pot" paid for by the public. UTB and TSC must invest in developmental programs before the college experience can begin. Its time for new leadership in BISD.
Ya apaciguence!
ZayCor la cagaron,dejaron la peste y ahora le echan la culpa a la gente que entro al restroom.
Que bueno que BISD no va defender a ZayCor, quien les manda ser gachos.
Post of Oct 12, @12:01pm
You are soooooo right!! BISD administrator are overpaid, as long as they ki$$ up tho the current $4board majority. It's time to clean up house starting at the top....
Yes, this post makes sense, and oh, so true. I know from first hand experience--an educational and business level. Dig for the truth and you will find out about what a joke our educational system is. Lord help the poor administrators who want to cover the truth to keep their jobs. Blow smoke by creating the illusion of a college prep high school and let the rest eat cake. In the end, Brownsville tax payers lose in many ways. By the way, when Brownsville tax payers voted for this bond to create this school, what were they told? If you search, you will see that this shift in focus for this school should not happen according to the initial plan.
Excellent post. Vocational arts is totally neglected at BISD, and TSC.
What's wrong with teaching subjects that are relavant, such as carpentry, auto mechanics, plumbing, machine shop, welding, hotel and restaurant management, health care, computers, and most important, reading, writing, and aritmatic.
A well trained work force is essential to economic development. Teach the kids a trade that can get them a real job. And get rig of lazy teachers who are not doing their jobs.
This year (first time in Hx) they removed ALL art classes at Russell Elementary.....
Excellent post to an excellent post. Get rid of Juliet Garcia.
The problem is that once the government got involved in education matters everything got complicated and the erosion of educating students began! If they'd allow the educators to teach what matters which are the three R's then we wouldn't be in this predicament! I don't believe that teachers are lazy! I think that some might be burned out with all the crap we have to put up with!!
I do not believe teachers are lazy. What I believe is that we, the parents, want to leave it ALL in the hands of the teachers. Let's work together towards the same goal after all, they are our kids.......
Magnet school at VMHS.....First teach them how to read PLEASE!!!
Post a Comment