By Juan Montoya
Who would have thought that the recurring clashes between Arabs and Jews in the Palestine would reach out and touch residents of South Texas?
The most recent bloody encounter has gone on for the last two weeks and more than 604 Palestinians and some 27 Israelis are dead, one of them a civilian and on a dual Israeli-U.S. citizen. Reports indicate that more than 70 percent of the Palestinian dead are civilians and that tens of thousands Palestinians in Gaza have been left homeless . Some 80 Palestinian victims were children.
The Israeli Consulate in Houston confirmed that 21-year-old Sgt. Nissim Sean Carmeli, who lived in South Padre Island, was among 13 Israeli soldiers and 65 Palestinians killed Sunday when the Israeli Army marched into the Gaza strip. Carmeli had moved to Israel about four years ago.
Many of us who have been watching this tragedy unfold are so far removed from the scene that – listening to the media blitz in the Sunday news talk shows – it would appear that the Jewish state was fighting for its life against "terrorists" and Hamas, the elected government of Gaza which Israel calls a "terrorist" organization.
In fact, the spiral of violence that has led to all-out war was started by isolated incidents by zealots on both sides that led to the conflagration.
This didn't start with the three Jewish teenagers killed and buried by unknown assailants, or by the four vigilantes who sought out Arab teens to kidnap and burn alive in retaliation for the murder of the three teens.
And despite what Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netayahu claims are the attempts of the Israeli military to minimize civilian casualties, the truth of the matter is that Israel is facing an overwhelmingly inferior fighting force which uses rockets without any semblance of guidance systems which are no match for the Jewish state's U.S-provided sophisticated armaments to lead the assault against the Palestinians.
Israel has courted the evangelical Christian element in the U.S. to buttress its claim that the entire Palestine formed Greater Israel of the Old Testament and therefore is entitled to reclaim it because of its people's antecedents to the land.
But if that was the measure, how about the the Chicanos and Mexican-Americans claims to Aztlan, their mythological homeland, now the U.S. Southwest?
No, this dispute goes much further back.
Following WW II, on May 14, 1948, David Ben-Gurion, the head of the Jewish Agency, proclaimed the establishment of the State of Israel. U.S. President Harry S. Truman recognized the new nation on the same day. The Arab-Israeli War of 1948 ultimately led to the displacement of hundreds of thousands of Palestinian Arabs.
Even before that, Jewish irregulars had been advocating the establishment of a Jewish state despite the fact that Palestine was populated by predominantly Arab countries.With the establishment of the partition of Palestine and the displacement of the Arab population there, it was a recipe for the disaster we're facing now.
Netanyahu and the spokesmen for the State of Israel can wring their hands and whine about the "terrorists" on the Sunday morning talk shows (and they did) all they want. But they know that the tens of thousands of newly-displaced refugees from Gaza are the direct result of the decades-long policies by Israel to marginalize the Arab majority.
U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry and President Barack Obama have shown that they are not honest brokers. They – along with conservative Republican hawk Lindsay Graham (R-S.C.), have given the Israeli Army the green light to enter and destroy the Palestinian state under the justification that everyone there is a "terrorist."
Funny, the images on television showing the blown up bodies of children and women "terrorists" don't appear to show them carrying weapons or firing rockets at the Israeli soldiers of civilians. Netanyahu said the army had tried through telephone calls, text messages and leaflets to warn civilians and get them to leave the area.
And where are they supposed to go? UN refugee centers are overwhelmed. Entire families are fleeing through the streets as Israeli tanks fire at them in the distance. There is no light at the end of that tunnel. In fact, there is no tunnel at all.
At the heart of the dispute is the fact that the last thing Israel wants is a Palestinian state and labels adherents to the idea "terrorists."
It wasn't that long ago that a small band of "freedom fighters" (or was it terrorists?) under the late Israeli Prime Minister Menachem Begin called the Irgun, carried out indiscriminate murders of innocent Arabs and even British soldiers in their quest for an independent state of Israel.
Wikipedia states that "During the 1936-39 Arab revolt in Palestine against the Mandatory Palestine, the militant Zionist group Irgun carried out 60 attacks against Palestinian Arabs and British soldiers. Irgun was described as a terrorist organization by The New York Times, the Anglo-American Court of Inquiry, and prominent world figures such as Winston Churchill, and Jewish figures such as Hannah Arendt, Albert Einstein, and many others. The Israeli Ministry of Foreign Affairs, on the other hand, describes it as "an underground organization. (Isn't today's Palestinian Hamas the equivalent of the Irgun?)"
The New York Times at the time cited sources in an investigative piece which linked the Haganah
paramilitary group to the Irgun terrorist attacks such as the King David Hotel bombing. Irgun launched a series of attacks which lasted until the beginning of World War II. All told, Irgun attacks against Arab targets resulted in at least 250 Arab deaths during this period."
We can only hope some sort of agreement will put the current troubles to an end. Right now Netanyahu and his U.S. allies in the mainstream media own the airwaves. But until the Arabs are given what Israel got through force of arms and their own brand of "benign terrorism," don't expect this tragedy to stop no matter how it's sugar coated.
Monday, July 21, 2014
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
15 comments:
I am used to anti- Anglo pieces, but this your first anti-Semetic blog. They really are two sides of the same coin. You search history for some wrong that justifies the current racism of others.
Israel has become the 51th state of the UNITED STATES of AMERICA.
The Republican party and some Democrats (all of them plutocrats) will literaly trip over themselves to bend over backwards to support Israel with United States taxpayer dollars. According to ForeignAssistance.gov, a government web site, Israel receives billions of US taxpayer dollars in foreign aid. Israel is receiving $3.1 billion in 2014 and $3.1 billion are proposed for 2015. All this "guided rockets" raining on the people of Palestine are courtesy of the US taxpayers.
Netanyahu and the AAIPAC (American Israel Public Affairs Commitee) have the US Congress wrapped around their fingers. Here and here you can hear Netanyahu bragging how America is a thing you can move very easily....
Republicans, the Tea Party, and Republican wannabe Henry Cuellar (he votes 60% of the time with the Republicans) have a problem with the poor innocent Central American kids arriving in this country to escape certain death if they return. However, they have no problem sending billions of Foreign Aid to Israel and other countries every frieking year. Cubans have to only set foot on USA ground and they are automatically granted citizenship.
Facts ALL US Citizens Need to Know About Israel and Palestine
So please spare me the faux internet rage calling this article anti-semitic!!
Your initial piece and follow up are pure Hamas propaganda and they are anti-Semetic without doubt.
In geo-politics we have spheres of influence and national interests. Israel is vital to the interests of the U.S. It is a buffer zone . It keeps those crazy Camel Drivers and their fanatical beliefs at bay. "The nations of the world have no friends ; only interests." C. De Gaulle.
Juan this is a wonderful piece of work. I sure would like to see the above anonymous person that is accusing you of being anti-Anglo as well as anti-Semitic to lay down some facts coupled with the accusation. It is too bad that Israel is being led by an extreme right wing party like the one that is trying to get into running our country. Israel’s right wing party is led by Netanyahu who is complete evil. The aid that we give to them comes back to our politicians in the form of lobby money. Our honest politicians can’t utter a word against Israel because they are immediately crucified as anti-Semitic. The Israel’s economy would be in shambles if they would be paying for their continuous war. One thing we have to be thankful to Putin is the fact that he saved us from getting into war with Syria. Israel has been trying to get us to take care of this back door neighbor as well as Iran for them. If it would be up to them as well as John McCain and Lindsey Graham we would have U.S. soldiers inside of Israel fighting the Palestinians so that the casualties would be ours instead.
in response to :
**********************************
Anonymous Anonymous said...
Your initial piece and follow up are pure Hamas propaganda and they are anti-Semetic without doubt.
July 22, 2014 at 11:12 AM
==================================
Typical reply when you don't have a counterpoint or defense!!
You don't like the article by JMon; You call it anti-semitic.
You don't like MY (not JMon) comment; You call it "propaganda"....
Peace!
Israel has the right to defend itself from Hamas. Palestine is not a country and There has been fighting since the beginning of time in the Middle East. Let us not forget Both Sadat and Begin were awarded the Nobel Peace Prize for creating the 1979 Peace Treaty. In his acceptance speech, Sadat referred to the long awaited peace desired by both Arabs and Israelis. We know this is a lie. Hamas and Hezbollah are terrorist organizations just like the Democratic Party all are poised to destroy America if we let them.
What do you expect the Palestinian people to do especially when genocide is being carried out by the Israel people? In other words reject the only help that is offered by Hezbollah and Hamas. The United States should stop turning a blind eye on these atrocities. We need peace in this region. The only way we are going to achieve peace in the middle east is by voting out of office all the Republican Tea Party Skinheads.
The Europeans came to America and displaced the Indians...get over it. The Anglo Texans and Tejanos kicked Santa Ana's ass out of Texas ..get over it. The US won the war with Mexico...get over it. The Anglos came to Cameron County and got rich..get over it. The Jews displaced by the Holocaust founded their own state called Israel....get over it.
None of these changes took place without winners and losers. Still folks cling to phony historic greviences and piss and moan about it all. Many try and convert these events to their own personal gain. Racism and racial politics is the order of the day for the losers.
Why don''t you losers try and become winners instead of whining. You are welcome to try. We will all pick a side and see how it plays out.
The Rabbi was born in Palestine. He was a Palestinian.
It is disgusting to read your comments which are full of hatred, greed and hypocrisy. In suggesting that we “get over it” certain things, I will start by mentioning the Holocaust. Have the Jews gotten over it? No, they haven’t, they have built museums and keep on pounding the drums as to the 11 million people they lost. Let me say that Jews were not the only ones killed there. There were many Poles, gypsies, Jehovah Witnesses, homosexuals, disabled as well as Protestant ministers that were sacrificed. I don’t see the them pounding the drums. You did not finish the sentence “The Anglos came to Cameron County and got rich..”. Let me finish off the sentence by inserting “off of the Tejanos by stealing their properties from them and killing them if they would not budge”. You sure don’t see the Tejanos committing genocide to the Anglos. We would be more justified since it was our land that was stolen from us. No, we haven’t forgotten about it even though some Anglos have tried writing history books with lies. I can tell that you are a Netanyahu follower since by your last paragraph you feel very confident if you would be in a dual. Well, if you and Netanyahu were so confident why try to involve the US in fighting your wars and aggression. Why do you want us to finance your war as well as the genocide of the Palestinian people? Go fight it alone. Get rid of your hatred maybe we can start having some peace.
Good piece. The comparison between Palestine and Aztlán/Southwest Borderlands can be fleshed out some more along the lines of settler-colonialism.
Hello. These Dudes have been at each others throats for the past 5,000 years.
A So. Texan has no business involving himself in Camel Driver's region. Like the late Henry Sánchez once said, " a Meskin has no business doing business in East Texas".
Some "Anglos" are Jews, but many Hispanics are Jews too. I am Jewish ; but I will buy Ham if it's on Sale.
Post a Comment