Wednesday, March 1, 2023

THE HUMAN COST OF DOWNTOWN B'VILLE GENTRIFICATION

By Juan Montoya

During the bottoms of the pandemic-fueled economic recession in downtown Brownsville, I made it a point to take my dry cleaning to L and M Dry Cleaners and Alterations on 934 E. Adams.

I'm retired, so I really didn't need my clothes washed and ironed. I could do that myself. But I could see that the dry cleaners – run by an elderly couple and their son, los Guzman – were struggling to stay open. Their three employees labored in the back of the cleaners washing and ironing the clothing of the store's loyal customers. As the pandemic lengthened, they could have fired them. But they didn't. So supporting this small business during the pandemic was a no-brainer.

They had been eking out a living for so long that even the schools of the Brownsville Independent School District brought their flags to be washed and cleaned. They were a part of the community. Then the influx of capital (grants) and the millions Elon Musk and the Brownsville Community Improvement Corporation  (BCIC) poured into downtown  created a frenzy of real-estate speculation.

The price of real estate zoomed through the roof. Downtown is no longer a place for honest, hard-working people. It has become a feeding trough for speculators and shysters. Old-time restaurants and cantinas which gave downtown its color have been driven out. Unless you are ready to plunk down close to $5 for a beer or close to $10 for a mixed drink or a high-brow glass of wine, don't even walk in the door. And forget about conjunto music.  

Then, just in the last month and a half, the cleaners closed. The reason wasn't because the elderly couple were tired, or retired. Their son told what had happened.

"The son of the owner (the late George Saenz) came in one day and told my dad that unless he had $300,000 to buy the store, he had a month to get out and vacate the building because he was going to try to sell it," he said.

"My dad was on medication and he pleaded with the owner's son to give him some time to remove all the equipment and service all the orders we had, but the guy refused. He said he could extend it only half a month and told him to get out in 45 days. My dad said he might need a little more time. The guy turns around and tells him that it sounded like a personal problem to him. I felt like punching him for talking to my dad like that. But he told us, after all those years, to get out."

 And so the son was placed in charge of removing all the washing, ironing, and dry cleaning machinery, laying off the workers, and cleaning the place up.

The abrupt change in their lives took its toll. His mother took ill. And his dad, under the pressure of a life-changing trauma, also took ill...and died. After surviving the pandemic and  weathering economic downturns, this killed him.

Peace be with him y que en paz descanse.

Those of us who patronized the little mom-and-pop dry cleaners downtown were surprised when we arrived with our clothing only find out that the couple –  who were always, always serviceable and courteous and knew us by our name – were no longer there and only a cavernous, empty, building could be seen through the large iron-barred, plate-glass storefront.

I only found out about it yesterday when I ran into their son and he told me the story. He is angry and missing his father. And he worries about his mother, whose life revolved around the business. I will miss her cheery greeting when I walked in the door. "Hola, senor Montoya!" 

We weren't just their customers. They were our friends, our neighbors.

The price of progress? For whom? Not for this hard-working family and their employees. Perhaps for some real-estate speculator who will flip the property and turn the store into an upscale night club or bistro that only a select few can afford. 

But is there a price that one can place on the life of everyday folks or the people they employed?

Gentrification, indeed.

41 comments:

Youtube said...

Social media live streaming

Anonymous said...

I remember when I was going to cummings before the zoo was built all of a sudden a dry cleaners opened shop there. It amazed everybody. What is a dry cleaners doing en este barrio? On the corner of ringgold and sixth st. Nobody in this area even thinks about a dry cleaners. We all noticed that it was never opened. Well than the city ran everybody living there out of that area and that store remained. Why? The zoo was coming, and who ever that store belonged to more than likely made millions. El ratismo sigue and will never stop. Downtown is the same. People that are related, cronies, compadres are given tips that are worth millions. It will never stop. RATISMO continues to this day. They fight to run for some elected office, just to make millions. That is the reason this city is a cesspool of RATAS.
OUR ONLY SOLUTION TO THIS AGED LONG PROBLME IS TO VOTE EVERYBODY OUT. PERIOD.

there is a need to organize and fight this RATISMO. an organization of honest citizens needs to be organized NOW.
One that will expose all RATAS. Volunteers are needed we need to organize NOW. No families of RATAS will be allowed to join. ORGANIZE NOW!!!

BobbyWC said...

Sometimes you cannot use local. But my tailor is a family business downtown. My shoe shop is currently 3rd generation. Juan when we both were growing up these businesses were the community.

I will never forget I got staph infection in my hands working at KFC. back then Epsom salt was the cure all. I went to the drug store to buy it. The pharmacist called my mother at work and before I knew it she was at home taking me to the ER. I spent a week with my hands tied over my head and on a lot of anti-biotics. You see these small family businesses knew the people and looked after us. When possible I will also use and send people to locally owned. My new truck came with windshield insurance, but I used a family business on Southmost many times for my other vehicles. They were fast and cheaper than that national company.

There is more than family owned businesses than a business. They get to know us and take care of us.

Bobby Wc

Anonymous said...

That is the price of revitalization of Downtown Brownsville. People come from other cities that they are priced out of to influence these posh places. The delusion of outsiders that the way to have fun is to pay for consumption and entertainment without hesitation. Influencers peddle their ideas to cater to their needs. Instagram worthy cute spots with overpriced food and spirits. I could careless this place has been cut and sold to the highest bidder. Just look at the comments at Juan Mendez facebook posts. They all want Trader Joe's, Cheescake Factory, COSTCO, etc. A consumer driven economy because no one knows what they want in life. As long as they consume mindlessly the corrupt individuals will line their pockets.

Anonymous said...

Brownsville plunging into the 1990s.

Commerce has its own lifeblood, and it is cash. Mom & Pop shops died a long time ago elsewhere. Even in the Bally.

No crying needed. Just matter-of-fact stuff. Montoya always goes for the sentimental angles. Good Mexican, he.


Anonymous said...



Saving Downtown Brownsville from progress is a loser's move. History? History does not pay the bills. Progress exacts a price, yes. But progress it must be for the most under-achieving city in the valley!

Put a dome over the shopping end of Elizabeth. Then the masses will come.....




Anonymous said...

It's a cruel & cold world, Monty.

You're weeping will do nothing to abate it. Nothing, ese.


fact,


Anonymous said...




Things die. Old Brownsville is dead. Bring on the new!


Anonymous said...

The pest BobbyWC has opened a new blog - in the comments of Barton's blog!


ja ja ja ja loser






Anonymous said...

Authorities cracking down on drag racing in parts of Cameron County
Arrest las RATAS always going after he poor PINCHES MAMONES

Anonymous said...

Man accused of killing 3 police officers dies in custody awaiting trial: Police
Was he at the local Jail????

Anonymous said...

Why hasn’t the DA charged anyone for the BPUB crimes committed as reported in the audit report?

Anonymous said...

In the late 50's and early 60's there were 2 maybe three stores for almost every block and one of them just had to be a tortilla store. The other two were run by grandma's. Every thing they sold was priced at a penny. Gum, loose cigarettes, candy, cookies you name it everything was a penny, but you had to listen to her advice and that was el pilon. Good old days.
NOT COMING BACK.

Anonymous said...

I was given a quarter on saturday to go to the movies. One nickel to go in, one nickel for a coke, one nickel for popcorn and one nickel for a candy bar. The left over nickel was for school on monday...
back in the 50's and 60's.

Anonymous said...

Posters send letters demanding
to stop spreading lies!
How do you know they are maricones or are pendejos and idiotas? sent in the proof. Is marcones and jotos the same so why the double branding? Oh ok I didn't know that!!! so sorrrrrrrrrrrrryyyyyy...




si, si son.

Anonymous said...

This is the reality and sometimes cruel nature of progress and change. Many will not like it but its the sad truth. Yes the “old days” were a nicer,respectful,humble and a more humane way of life. That was a beautiful era but unfortunately that era is gone. I remember all the stories about old Brownsville told by my grandparents/parents and how much simpler and beautiful life was back then. Well like they say “all good things must come to an end”. Yes thats so true . But lets just analyze one thing here: Brownsville is changing, new, different types of businesses will flourish and $$$ money will be made, but to these new entrepreneurs/business owners it’s important to embrace change but don’t forget or disrespect the past history and the people that worked so hard to create the foundation of our town. Many of grandparents and parents worked long hours to raise their families and to make our town special. Good luck and may God bless this new era in our town and don’t forget to treat each other with respect and dignity. And to that person that did that to that business and its owners you could of handled it much differently. I understand , business is business but your cutthroat approach with these people was cowardly. “There are many ways to skin a cat “ like the saying goes, and you sir failed miserably!! That is my opinion and thats all for today. Thanks

Anonymous said...

Poor Mr Saenz kids already selling off his hard work

Anonymous said...

Brownsville lacking bus stop shelters?

Read this about Los Angeles:

Woe to the person waiting for a bus in torrential rain or a heat wave. At the vast majority of stops across the region, bus riders will find no shelter from the storm or the blazing sun. Just 1 in 4 stops served by Los Angeles County Metropolitan Transportation Authority buses provide cover from the weather, according to a new analysis.

It’s a sign of how little thought or planning has gone toward improving conditions for bus riders in Los Angeles County, despite voters backing four sales tax increases since 1980 to pay for transportation projects and programs. More than 560,000 people ride Metro buses every day. What should be a simple, basic amenity of bus service — a bench to sit on and some shade while waiting — is still a rarity in most areas of the county.


wow.


Anonymous said...

So under your theory montoya an old business that never innovated should be allowed to pay cheap rent forever. Got it.

Anonymous said...

That's why I will always go to Chico's instead of pep boys. Keep up the good work

Anonymous said...

God Bless America.

Anonymous said...

There was nothing, NOTHING better than having a cold beer at la tejanita and hearing Araguz play his accordion accompanied by the bajo sexto of the day he could find sober. Reyna's , La Movida, El Capitan , Arturo's place had more soul and ambiance than any you will find in any of the Hoydi Toydi fresa filled bars downtown today. Besides the fact that parking is non-existent, downtown has no future. Us Meskins like cheap drinks that get you drunk fast. Bring back Las Pantaletas, Cantinas, and Musicos and Watch downtown flourish.

Anonymous said...

Yeah, I was there a month ago and the nice lady sadly turned away my business and then told me that they were no longer accepting any orders cause they had been asked to leave the building and that they were already dismantling things in the back, while banging and clinging noises could be heard in the back.

Don't be surprised if Las Cazuelitas closes too. Word in downtown is that the gay club next to both the cleaners and Cazuelitas wants the whole corner to expand.

Anonymous said...

Y aqui que? -


McAllen is set to welcome a new restaurant from renowned restaurateur Jaime Muriel, who will open the doors to his latest addition in North McAllen this month.

Ambra will have its grand debut in mid-March at 1200 Auburn Avenue.

The “globally-inspired” menu will offer meat, fish, seafood and vegetable dishes inspired by Argentinian, Peruvian and other South American countries.

“We’re excited to bring a new high-end dining experience to North McAllen,” Muriel stated in a news release. “Our goal is to provide our guests with an unforgettable culinary experience, exceptional service, and a warm and inviting atmosphere. We look forward to welcoming everyone to Ambra.”


Anonymous said...

White House pitches $1.6 billion plan to combat Covid relief fraud
Not for you pendejos its for the da's like the one we have here to distribute to all his family and friends. Expect higher property taxes to increase....

Anonymous said...

PEOPLE HERE DON'T NOT WANT TO RE-ELECT ANYBODY, WE NEED CHANGE WE NEED TO KICK OUT ALL LAS RATAS OUT OF THE CITY, COUNTY, PORT, BISD you name it, THEY ALL HAVE TO GO...
STOP CRONISM, COMPADREISM, COMPADREISM, VOTING FRIENDS, STOP THE HIRING OF YOUR FAMILIES, UNQUALIFIED VOTING FRIENDS THIS NEEDS TO STOP!!!

START A HOME IMPOVEMENT PROGRAN HERE WHERE ITS NEEDED NOT GIVE IT TO OTHER COUNTRIES OR PEOPLE THAT DO NOT LIVE HERE. STOP ALL THE NON-SENSE PROJECTS THAT DO NOTHING FOR THE CITY MURALS, BIKE TRAILS ETC ETC ETC.

SUE BPUB TO GIVE THE MONEY THAT WAS STOLEN, BACT TO THE TAXPAYERS AND TAKE ALL OF THEM TO JAIL. START AN INVESTIGATION NOW.

FIX THE STREETS, TRAFFIC LIGHTS, FLOODING, START AN AIRPORT, BUS SHELTERS, STOP THE SENSELESS SPENDING.
FREEZE HIGH PAYING JOBS INCREASES, SALARIES BUT NOT THE WORKING EMPLOYEES.
MOST IMPORTANT DO NOT RE-ELECT NOBODY NOT EVEN TO A DIFFERENT POSITION DO NOT RE-ELECT NOBODY...RATAS

Anonymous said...

So the downtown area has been revitalized for the fags and the caritas. Wow! Times are changing. I guess its fair to say it was better in the old days.

Anonymous said...

Casa Antigua Restaurant (Central Blvd in front of Don Johnson's car dealership) possibly closing soon due to property owner trying to develop property

Anonymous said...

It's Anglification, not gentrification Monty. We are losing the Valley to Millenials who embrace this rootless Anglo culture whose only currency is money. Sad to see our roots drying up. Where's Ramon Ayala and Cornelio and Eliseo. Lagrimas we Cuauhtémoc

Anonymous said...

I know the rich and famous here, are never seen shopping not even on their own local stores and only during election times. The are the ones that finance all the pachangas here. feed the poor but make them vote for US, and the cocos oblige.
Nothing new here. The original RATAS that stole all the lands started this.

Anonymous said...

March 1, 2023 at 8:31 PM

Couldn't of said it better so true, specially las pantelatas.

Anonymous said...

March 1, 2023 at 4:54 PM
about time pendejo can't make it more simple

Anonymous said...

Pest hahahahaha jajajajaja pest!!!! haaaahahahaha so funny

Anonymous said...

loser haaaaahahahahah jajajaja keep em coming Juanito ooooops its not juanito sooooooooooooooooooooooooooo rrrrry.......
but its funny loser hahahahahaa jajajaja

Anonymous said...

Brownsville, TX (WBAP/KLIF) – A Texas city was taken by surprised when Elon Musk tweeted on Tuesday that he would donate $30 million to revitalize it and its schools, after appealing to people to move there to work for SpaceX.

Billionaire techie Elon Musk tweeted Friday that he was donating $20 million to schools in Cameron County in Southeast, TX and $10 million to revitalize the city, home to one of the company’s rocket-production facilities and close to the launch site in Boca Chica, which Musk has said he wants to grow into a city called Starbase.

The problem here is that the schools gave themselves a hefty pay raise so all that funding is LONG GONE.
Gacias Elton Muskies.

Anonymous said...

If you really want to go back, bring back The Tampico Bar, The Pilot Bar, The Chicago Bar and the Tip Top Lounge. And of course the ladies of the night that hung out at 11th and E. Jefferson.

Anonymous said...

March 2, 2023 at 6:19AM

I hope my comment helps you. Stop lamenting what Brownsville does not have and move to McAllen. As someone who lived in McAllen I prefer Brownsville. The people over there are shady but don't take my word. Go and experience new opportunities for yourself.

Anonymous said...

Harold Jose Jimenez:

my butler is 4th generation from a locally owned business and all my business is done only with local businesses. I have done this ever since I first purchased my first penny candy from Dona Conchita, she ran a local candy tienda.

Anonymous said...

this is a blog idiota non-formal joto go to bisd and try to teach

Anonymous said...

March 2, 2023 at 5:52 PM
best idea yet.

Anonymous said...

el sportsman, el barril barrel lounge y el 1 2 3.

rita