By Juan Montoya
By now, only the most gullible history students believe that the Mexican-American War was caused by a random confrontation between a detail of Zachary Taylor's Army of Occupation and Mexican forces along the Rio Grande.
From the beginning move by President James Polk when he ordered Taylor south from the Nueces River to the north bank of the Rio Grande to increase the pressure on the Mexican government to negotiate for the sale of California and the pushing of the Texas border to the Rio Grande, the strategy was one bent on creating a confrontation to justify the invasion into Mexican territory.
Taylor first met resistance from the Mexicans at the Arroyo Colorado when Mexican vaqueros said they would attack if his troops crossed the arroyo. Taylor pushed on and the vaqueros disappeared into the chaparral. One of these vaqueros might well have included Juan Nepomuceno Cortina, a local rancher and heir to the Espiritu Santo Grant, whose northern fringes abutted the Arroyo Colorado. In other words, Cortina, if he was there, was standing on his own land.
Then, on March 28, 1846, Taylor started constructing Ft. Texas directly across the river from Matamoros as Mexican officials and residents looked on from the opposite bank.
When Mexican officials protested, he answered by blockading the mouth of the Rio Grande and disrupting the flow of commerce and communications between Matamoros and New Orleans and Mexico City.
Later, Taylor sent raiding parties across the river to search for armed parties in Mexico and engage them. In one such engagement a Lt. Porter and one mare were killed.
It was on the 24th of April that Taylor finally got his wish. He sent Capt. Seth T
hornton and 52 dragoons ostensibly on a reconnaissance mission to ascertain the crossing above river of a sizeable Mexican force under the command of Gen. Anastacio Torrejon.

According to Capt. William Hardee, an officer in the detachment, he said Taylor's order to Thornton "as I understood them, were to ascertain if the enemy had crossed the river above our camp, and to reconnoiter his position and force."
According to Hardee, no mention was made of confronting the enemy or engaging them in battle.
However, Thorton seems to have been under other orders from Taylor.
Hardee notes in a letter he wrote to Taylor on April 26 as a prisoner of the Mexican forces in Matamoros two days after Thornton was ambushed, that on the 25th "all his inquiries along the way tended to the conviction that the enemy had crossed in strength."
About 23 miles from our camp (Rancho Carrizitos) our guide became so satisfied of this fact that he refused to go further and no entreaties on the part of Capt. Thornton could shake his resolution."
That guide was a spy named Chepita, a servant of Col. Henry L. Kinney, a contraband runner and founder of Corpus Christi, who tagged along with his employer who had signed on with the army to procure supplies for Taylor and provide the general with intelligence from behind enemy lines.
The result of Thornton disregarding Chepita's information – and Hardee's reason to be perplexed with his commander's decision to confront the enemy in apparent contradiction to his orders – was the capture of more than 40 U.S. soldiers, the death of seven dragoons and the wounding of the rest.
When Taylor got word of the encounter, he mailed Polk a dispatch stating that "hostilities may now be considered as commenced."
Polk then announced to Congress and the world, " Mexico has passed the boundary of the United States, has invaded our territory and shed American blood upon the American soil."
On May 13, 1846, Congress declared war on Mexico, despite protests by the Mexican government . Mexico officially declared war on July 7.
5 comments:
There is a problem in your own writing Juanito. Hardee admits the enemy had crossed the Rio Grande which was the border whether you want to believe it or not. Even the spy agreed it happened.
The Mexican Army did kill Americans on American soil.
Thorton disregarded the order? Oh really? Is it plausible that Thorton was attacked and did not disgregard any order other than to defend himself?
Sounds to me like Hadee would hang out fine with Oliver Stone believing Thorton was under different orders. And even if Thorton was, so what? Mexicans killed Americans on American soil because Mexican's crossed it. Why did they cross it? I thought they were all were proto-peaceniks or proto-hippies. Shouldn't America defend itself, Mssr. Chicano? Oh that's right, the border crossed us or some bull shit like that.
One other thing is the national guard along our modern border an "occupational force"?
The Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo signed in February 1848 (two years after the Thornton Affair) established the Rio Grande as the border. Virtually no historian accepts that the Rio Grande was the border in 1846. U.S. Rep. Abraham Lincoln dissented on Polk's assertion that "American blood has been shed on American soil" and asked him to point to the exact spot and if the residents there had evern paid taxes or pledged allegiance to the United States, etc., etc., etc. Hardee was no liberal. He went on to join the Confederacy and fought against the union. Thornton was not attacked. He walked into an ambush even after his guide told him there was a large body of the enemy there. Unless we are to believe that Thornton was a loose cannon (and nothing in his previous service or subsquent actions in Mexico suggests that), the possibility remains very real that he was under secret orders from Taylor to engage the enemy and provide Polk with his justification for war.
Virtually no historian? Juanito, it's because academia is essentially covered in the feces that is liberalism. You do realize that the War you speak of is of little importance in American history, and your sources will in all likelihood be Mexican or Mexican friendly historians. Texans and Polk recognized the border as the Rio Grande. Whig opponents were the one's angered by Polk's policies that accounted for their distaste of the true border.
No on is claiming Hardee was a liberal. He is a conspiracy nut who thought Thornton was doing things out of the ordinary because of some communication Thorton must have had with Taylor. People walk into ambushes all the time. Mexico was inflamed for four months prior to April of that year. They wanted war with the United States as much if not more than you claim the United States through Polk were instigating war with our southern neighbor.
I'm shocked you did not point to a letter where an American colonel claims they had no right to be at Fort Texas/Brown. He believed the government sent a small force to be attacked. He was just a wimp who failed to understand that although the Mexicans wanted war that they were not necessarily prepared for war along the border. Sending a small army to the border, as Polk did, is because they were not planning on invading or occupying Mexico. Sending a large amount of troops would lend credence to your theory the American government was invading Mexico. I know Polk already had his speech ready to declare war before he sent Taylor. Isn't it fair to say that a government should be prepared for everything and anything.
John Seigenthaler wrote a biography on James K. Polk. He recognized the border as the Rio Grande.
Are you one of these moron amateur historians who believe that Texas was annexed as opposed to admitted into the Union?
Hay tu 'pos ' Ora si qui 'Tamos requiti bien Jodidos y Amolados batos, ' pos No que el Tal Bush era Joto ?
Most U.S.A. Territories and " Expanded Empire Lands ", were a result of planning cospiracies, cover - ups and complots against The other nations. Provocations, secret Guerrillas,
" Divide and Conquer' was and still is the operandus mode. That's how Hawaii, Puerto Rico, the U.S. virgin islands, Alaska, Northern Mexico, The Panama Channel, and so on...
Now, They are conpiracing again at teh rest of what is left of The Northern States, By selling / crossing fire arms to the Narcos...
Before China " Takes" Them ahead of the U.S.A.
Due to its perfect Geographical territorial location for trading: North - to- South by land and East - to west by Sea.
Post a Comment