Monday, June 20, 2016

DOES CARLOS ELIZONDO HAVE TO RESIGN HIS BISD SEAT?

Section 702: Political Activity
"B. Specifically, City Employees may not engage in the following activities:
4. Hold an elective City office or hold an elective or appointive office in any other jurisdiction where service would constitute a direct conflict of interest with City employment, with or without remuneration. Upon assuming such office, an Employee shall resign or shall be dismissed for cause upon failure to do so."

By Juan Montoya
As the new fire chief for the Brownsville Fire Department, Carlos Elizondo is directly responsible for the enforcement of fire codes, inspections, and for the uniform applications of all regulations having to do with fire prevention rules on facilities construction.
However, while he wears one hat as the city's new fire chief, Elizondo also wears another hat, that of a trustee on the board of the Brownsville Independent School District.
As such, he has the power and authority to overturn decisions made by fire-code inspectors and firefighters under his command which could be interpreted to constitute a direct conflict of interest. As one of the entities involved in facilities construction, the city has a very close (and continuing) relationship with the fire department, and their trustee.
We recall the issue of water pressure at Veterans Memorial High School almost stopped the construction because of the fire-fighting requirements and the safety of the staff and students.  If Elizondo had been fire chief, would things have been handled a bit different? Would corners have been cut that would have affected the safety of the staff and students there?
See how a potential conflict of interest develops very quickly when the fire chief is also a school district trustee? The policy, it appears, was adopted by the City of Brownsville for a reason.
We have been told that the district's administration is mulling over the Elizondo issue and looking for a resolution to the potential conflict of interest.
Now, who will take the bull by the horns? We doubt the City of Brownsville administration with its ethically-challenged counsel Mark Sossi will call forth the issue. And we also doubt that the BISD administration – which counts on his vote with the majority – will do anything about this either.
But just suppose that someone calls forth the issue in a courtroom. Would the city personnel policy on its employees (especially a department head) not holding elective or appointive office in annother jurisdiction survive the test?
If Elizondo has to resign as BISD trustee, will the rest of the board wait until the general election in November, or will they try to appoint someone who will have the advantage of incumbency to help him (or her) win the spot then?
Ideally, the voters of the district should decide who sits there. But will the boad le the people choose?

15 comments:

Anonymous said...

And the plot thickens!

Anonymous said...

This issue should have been addressed and resolved before he was appointed Fire Chief. Again, the city fails to flesh out personnel issues. Way to go Charlie Cabler!

Anonymous said...

The Fire Chief answers to the Mayor and City Manager. The City Manager answers to the City Council. For the Fire Chief to hold a seat on the City Council is a clear conflict of interest. To leave him on the City Council would mean the City Manager, his superior would be answering to him.

I should think this is a no brainer. But we are living in a world of palanca and Mexican thinking, so maybe it is confusing to many.

Anonymous said...

OK...Scrap my last comment. The Fire Chief is on the BISD board and not the City Council. My bad. I should pay closer attention to Mexican politics. I don't see a conflict with the Fire Chief serving on the BISD board.

Anonymous said...

Robert Rodriguez would be an excellent person to replace Carlos Elizondo on the BISD Board of Trustee. Mr. Rodriguez is a highly respected individual who lost to Mr. Elizondo in the last board election. Mr. Rodriguez would bring integrity and respect to the BISD Board of Trustee along with his experience as a retired school administrator.

Anonymous said...

I'm sure lopez owes someone a favor and will vote to appointment someone
Just like he was appointed

Pat Ahumada said...

It's called the Hatch Act, which was used to get Butch Baroda to resign back in 1992. The Hatch Act is to ensure federal funded programs are administered in a nonpartisan way. It's original intent was to prohibit federal employees from influencing elections and has since been amended to do the same in state and local government. Having said this, it is subject to enforcement which was not applied to Atkinson, when it should have and should be applied now to Elizondo and Trevino who is legal counsel to PUB who has received federal grants.

Anonymous said...

Gees, give the guy a chance..typical of us Mexicans.....like crabs in a bucket as they say... Pulling each other down.

Anonymous said...

Anonymous at 1:08. The only confused one here is you ! Get your facts straight before throwing insults .

Anonymous said...

Thanks Pat
It almost seems weird for you to be the voice of reason, but so be it, you know your stuff.

Anonymous said...

Are we talking about Rx Police chief Rodriguez?

Anonymous said...

For all those "anglos" here complaining about mexicanadas, read into the Iran Contra scandal or the US Presidential elections in 2000 in Florida, Watergate Scandal and more!. Mexicanadas are like a crawling baby and US scandals are like Usain Bolt running. Not defending mexicanadas or scandals.. just saying - deja de darte golpes de pecho.

Anonymous said...

Pat Ahumada ya parale tu pedo. No one believes you anyway. Why not just create your own blog. You continue to post on everybodies blog like if they write just for you. No one is going to elect you again. You had your chance twice and twice you lost and screwed things up yourself. You have no one to blame but you. For you to continue posting like your opinion is going to influence elected officials to change their mind or vote you way is not only stupid on your part but childish. Let it go. No one likes reading your opinion.
We know you are trying to be relevant gearing up for another election that you will lose. So please spare us your self righteousness like you are savior.

Pat Ahumada said...

Anonymous 1:14 PM, the only one who is irrelevant is you. Sign your name if you believe what you write. Lol!

Anonymous said...

Pat you're an idiot

rita